Here’s a bold statement: In a world where athletes often chase the biggest paycheck, Max Muncy is choosing loyalty over lucre, and it’s a decision that’s both refreshing and thought-provoking. But here’s where it gets controversial—is he leaving millions on the table, or is he gaining something far more valuable? Let’s dive in.
Last season, as the Dodgers’ roster shifted dramatically, Muncy found himself on the brink of becoming the team’s longest-tenured player. Austin Barnes and Chris Taylor were gone, Clayton Kershaw was eyeing retirement, and suddenly, the 35-year-old third baseman realized he’d be the last man standing from his 2018 arrival. ‘It was a wild thought,’ Muncy told The California Post, ‘but it’s definitely a blessing. I’m really grateful for it.’
Since reviving his MLB career with the Dodgers nearly a decade ago, Muncy has had one goal: to stay in Los Angeles for the rest of his playing days. This commitment is evident in his contract choices. In 2020, he bypassed arbitration for a three-year, $26 million deal. Later, he agreed to club-friendly extensions instead of testing free agency. And this winter, after the Dodgers exercised their 2026 option, Muncy eagerly pursued another extension, culminating in this week’s $10 million pact through 2027.
‘I’m very happy with where I’m at,’ Muncy said. ‘We reached an agreement that felt fair to both sides.’ But here’s the part most people miss—Muncy could have pursued a far more lucrative path. Despite recent injuries, he remains one of baseball’s most productive third basemen, coming off a 2025 season where he hit .243 with 19 home runs and 67 RBIs in 100 games. If he replicates those numbers in 2026, he could’ve commanded more than the $7 million his new contract guarantees.
‘I know I’m leaving some money on the table,’ Muncy admitted. ‘But I want to end my career here. Chasing money somewhere else wouldn’t make me happy. I’ve built too many relationships, and this is where I belong.’
But is he selling himself short? Some might argue that Muncy’s new deal is below market value. His contract includes incentives—up to $2.25 million this season based on plate appearances—and salary escalators for 2027. If the Dodgers pick up his 2028 option, he’ll have similar incentives. Yet, the industry buzz is that he could’ve gotten more.
For Muncy, though, staying in LA is priceless. ‘Would we really be happy chasing money while watching the Dodgers win the World Series?’ he asked. ‘No. I wouldn’t be able to live with myself knowing I’m not part of that success.’ Family stability also played a huge role. With three children, including a newborn, Muncy’s roots in LA run deep. ‘My kids were born here,’ he said. ‘The Dodgers are all they know. LA means something to them.’
And then there’s his role within the organization. Muncy feels he has ‘real input’ with the coaching staff and front office, a level of involvement he wouldn’t want to rebuild elsewhere. If he plays through 2028, he’ll likely retire at 38, preferring to leave the game on his terms rather than being forced out.
So, here’s the question for you: Is Muncy’s decision a smart move, or is he undervaluing himself? Let us know in the comments. And while you’re at it, stay connected with The California Post for more stories like this. Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube to keep up with the latest in sports, news, and opinion. Download our app or sign up for our newsletters to never miss a beat!
